Cagley Cemetery

located at 2599 Cheyenne Avenue, Nashua, IA 50658

This page is a transcription of data from a complete photo survey taken in 2022 by county coordinator Bruce Kuennen. This data was combined with the information recorded by the WPA in the 1930s. Finally, the data was supplemented by the information on a sign erected at the cemetery, perhaps in the 2010s (judging by the fading of the lettering on the sign).

There are now gravestone photos of all existing gravestones on the IGPP, as of 2022. As it turns out, the data on the sign is the most complete. There are a total of 89 burials accounted for; 84 of these are listed on the sign, 28 were included by the WPA, and the IGPP has 49 entries. The table below represents the information taken from all three sources. In a few cases, the information varied slightly between the three sourece; the county coordinator used his best judgment to determine the best interpretation of the data.

Cemetery from Above
LASTFIRSTDATES / INSCRIPTIONSIGPPWPASIGN
ALLENGrace D. Baby11 Jul 1924 - 14 Jul 1924  Sign
BACHGloria4 Apr 1921 - 8 Apr 1921  Sign
BECKCevilah M. (Cagley)15 Jul 1840 - 11 Dec 1868, Wife of John B. Beck, Aged 28 y, 4 m, 26 d.IGPPWPASign
BROOKSMary E.Abt 1854 - 17 Sep 1881, Aged 27 y, 4 m, 2 d, Wife of A. H. BrooksIGPPWPASign
CAGLEYBeatriceAbt 1902 - 15 Feb 1903  Sign
CAGLEYBertha E.Abt 1891 - 6 Apr 1891IGPP Sign
CAGLEYCalvin M.Abt 1873 - 22 Oct 1874IGPP Sign
CAGLEYCharles A.1864 - 15 Mar 1876, Aged 11 y, 10 m, 27 dIGPP Sign
CAGLEYCharlotte A. (Carey)22 Nov 1845 - 30 Nov 1907, His WifeIGPPWPASign
CAGLEYChristian McClellan26 Mar 1862 - 16 Feb 1890  Sign
CAGLEYClydeJan 1890 - 28 May 1890IGPP Sign
CAGLEYElizabeth (Keasling)28 Sep 1822  - 12 Sep 1893   WPASign
CAGLEYEva Hilderbrand2 Feb 1824 - 19 Mar 1897  Sign
CAGLEYGrant Hugh1921 - 28 Oct 1921IGPP Sign
CAGLEYHenrietta WaiteUnknown  Sign
CAGLEYInfant3 Apr 1866 - 3 Apr 1866   Sign
CAGLEYInfantUnknown  Sign
CAGLEYInfant s/of Geo & AAbt 1898 - 12 May 1898  Sign
CAGLEYJamesUnknown  Sign
CAGLEYJohn L. Jr.19 Feb 1840  - 27 May 1910  wife Charlotte A. IGPPWPASign
CAGLEYJohn Sr. 1786  - 4 Mar 1857  wife Susan IGPPWPASign
CAGLEYLevi  10 Jul 1818 - 22 Apr 1872   WPASign
CAGLEYLylian Edith1 Mar 1868 - 12 Nov 1868, Aged 8 m, 5 dIGPP Sign
CAGLEYMalissa J.Apr 1860 - 9 May 1860 ,Aged 15 das, Daughter of M. & E. CagleyIGPP Sign
CAGLEYMaria Ricky11 Aug 1830  - 29 Jun 1871   WPASign
CAGLEYMary Alice7 Oct 1860 - 19 Nov 1890IGPP Sign
CAGLEYMary J. (Wilcox)Abt 1857 - 20 Sep 1874IGPPWPASign
CAGLEYMichael20 Oct 1816 - 3 Apr 1881, Aged 65y, 5m, 13d Wife ElizabethIGPPWPASign
CAGLEYRoy J.Unknown  Sign
CAGLEYSamuel9 Apr 1832 - 11 Dec 1876 Wife MariaIGPP Sign
CAGLEYStephen Andrew1866 - 2 Apr 1867, Aged 4 m, 26 dIGPP Sign
CAGLEYSusan 1792  - 24 May 1873   WPA 
CAGLEYWilliam Henry20 Jun 1864 - 1882  Sign
CAREYAnson   26 Sep 1820  - 23 May 1893  1st wife, Polly Ann; 2nd Wife, Mary Ann IGPPWPASign
CAREYDaughter19 Aug 1856 - 19 Feb 1858IGPP  
CAREYMary12 Jul 1876 - 7 May 1880  Sign
CAREYMary Ann (Huffman)20 Jul 1837 - 19 Mar 1898IGPPWPASign
CAREYPolly Ann Weston20 Nov 1826 - 28 Aug 1856IGPPWPASign
CUFFELAnnie R. (Cagley)Abt 1849 - 5 Nov 1884, age 35, Wife of H. W. CuffelIGPPWPASign
CUNNINGHAMLauraAbt 1884 - 15 Apr 1885  Sign
DICKERSONMartha A.1865  - 8 Nov 1898  wife of T. R. Dickerson  WPASign
HANSONPearl1882 - 10 Jul 1882, Aged 3 w, 5 dIGPP Sign
HINEJames Philip1818 - 1874IGPP Sign
KEASLINGAbraham1850 - 1 Feb 1865IGPP Sign
KEASLINGAnnaAbt 1803 - 15 Apr 1881  Sign
KEASLINGJacob A.1872 - 15 Mar 1873, Aged 10 m, 15 d, Son of J. & S. KeaslingIGPP Sign
KEASLINGJacob O. 1825  - 25 Jun 1899  b. Sullivan Co., PA; wife Sarah  WPASign
KEASLINGSarah (Cagley)4 May 1826 - 15 Mar 1892, Aged 65 y, 10 m, Wife of Jacob KeaslingIGPPWPASign
KEASLINGSusannah "Hanna"Abt 1851 - 27 Sep 1866, Aged 15 y, 4 m, 7 d, Daughter of J. & Sarah KeaslingIGPP Sign
KIRKPATRICKGeorge W.Abt 1873 - 11 Feb 1880, Son of E. & H. Kirkpatrick, Aged 7 y, 6 m, and 7 dIGPP Sign
KIRKPATRICKLucy1869 - 4 Jan 1872, Aged 2 y, 5 mIGPP Sign
KIRKPATRICKMargaretAbt 1800 - 29 Dec 1877, Aged 77 y, Wife of Hugh Kirkpatrick,IGPP Sign
KIRKPATRICKMoughey1879 - 14 Feb 1880  Sign
MILLERAnna Madsen14 Jan 1828 - Abt 1888  Sign
MILLERAnna 1828  - 19 Nov 1887   WPASign
MILLERHansDec 1829 - 5 Apr 1900  Sign
MILLERHarris 1829  - 5 Apr 1902  wife Anna  WPASign
MILLERTenay3 Jan 1863 - 13 Oct 1876  Sign
MOTRYClaudiusAbt 1889 - Feb 1889  Sign
RANCHJohn1820 - 2 Aug 1866  Sign
RIBBLESusanah16 Dec 1792 - 24 May 1873, wife of John Cagley, Sr.IGPP Sign
SCHOENFELDWillemennaAbt 1833 - 9 Oct 1879  Sign
SCOLESEllis Abt 1833 - 28 Jul 1893  h/o Mary  WPASign
SCOLESG. H. 1808  - 22 Dec 1887  h/o Matilda WPASign
SCOLESHeadley1869 - 6 Jan 1880, Son of E. & M. Scoles, Aged 10 yearsIGPP Sign
SCOLESJohn H.1859 - 3 Aug 1888, Aged 28y, 10m, 27dIGPPWPASign
SCOLESMalinda "Matilda"1801 - 27 Jul 1881, Aged 79y, 10m, 6dIGPP Sign
SCOLESMaryAbt 1826 - 31 Dec 1891, aged 65   Sign
SHORTAnna Jane1853 - 15 Oct 1881, Aged 28 y, 2 m, 20 d, Wife of D. B. ShortIGPPWPASign
SHUETSFrank   Sign
SNYDERUnknown2 Feb 1891 - 4 Jan 1903IGPP  
STUFFLEJohn25 May 1826 - 3 Aug 1865, Husband of MaryIGPPWPASign
STUFFLELulu15 Jan 1892 - 5 Nov 1906  Sign
STUFFLEMary Keasling25 Nov 1832 - 22 Mar 1912IGPP Sign
STUFFLEValentine7 Mar 1858 - 31 Jan 1874IGPP Sign
STUFFLEWilliam15 Mar 1856 - 12 Feb 1880IGPP Sign
TROUTNERInfant DaughterAbt 1878 - 5 Sep 1878, Daughter of Peter & Sarah Troutner  Sign
TROUTNERInfant SonAbt 1880 - 4 Jun 1880, Son of Peter & Sarah TroutnerIGPP Sign
UNKNOWNMartha M.1892 - 1913IGPP  
WHISENNANDAnnie1803 - 15 Apr 1881, Aged 77 y, 8 m, 9 dIGPP Sign
WILCOXWilliam B.1849 - 28 Jul 1877, Aged 28 y & 2 m, Son of O. & E. WilcoxIGPP Sign
WILSONA. H.5 Jan 1843 - 15 Feb 1880  Sign
WILSONHenry1863 - 1902IGPPWPASign
WILSONJuda1828 - 1895IGPP Sign
WILSONLloydAbt 1894 - 15 Mar 1896  Sign
WILSONMahlon 1820  - 1894IGPPWPASign
WILSONUnknownAge 37  - d. 15 Feb 1880  neither name nor sex given  WPASign
WILSONUnknown1842 - 15 Feb 1880, Aged 37 y, 4 m, 10 dIGPP Sign
WILSONWillie1895 - 22 Mar 1897  Sign