| 1856 | James Buchanan (Democratic) | 62 |
| | John C. Fremont (Republican) | 19 |
| 1860 | Abraham Lincoln (Republican) | 100 |
| | Stephen A. Douglas (Democratic) | 64 |
| 1864 | Abraham Lincoln (Republican) | 78 |
| | George B. McClellan (Democratic) | 80 |
| 1868 | U. S. Grant (Republican | 151 |
| | Horace Seymour (Liberal) | 124 |
| 1872 | U. S. Grant (Republican) | 350 |
| | Horace Greeley (Liberal) | 145 |
| 1876 | Rutherford B. Hayes (Republican) | 876 |
| | Samuel J. Tilden (Democratic) | 631 |
| 1880 | James A. Garfield (Republican) | 1,499 |
| | W. S. Hancock (Democratic) | 963 |
| | James B. Weaver (Greenback) | 99 |
| 1884 | James G. Blaine (Republican | 1,802 |
| | Grover Cleveland (Democratic) | 1,745 |
| 1888 | Benjamin Harrison (Republican) | 1,714 |
| | Grover Cleveland (Democratic) | 1,762 |
| 1854 | Curtis Bates (Democratic) | 33 |
| | James W. Grimes (Whig) | 19 |
| 1857 | Ralph P. Lowe (Republican) (No vote shown.). |
| 1859 | A. C. Dodge (Democratic) | 96 |
| | S. J. Kirkwood (Republican) | 78 |
| 1861 | S. J. Kirkwood (Republican) | 99 |
| | Scattering (Democratic) | 36 |
| 1863 | William M. Stone (Republican) | 80 |
| | J. M. Tuttle (Democratic) | 82 |
| 1863 | William M. Stone (Republican) | 80 |
| | J. M. Tuttle (Democratic) | 82 |
| 1865 | William M. Stone (Republican) | 73 |
| | T. H. Burton (Democratic) | 74 |
| | G. S. Bailey | 7 |
| 1867 | Samuel Merrill (Republican) | 107 |
| | Charles Mason (Democratic) | 109 |
| 1869 | Samuel Merrill (Republican) | 116 |
| | George Gillaspy (Democratic) | 90 |
| 1871 | Cyrus C. Carpenter (Republican) | 285 |
| | J. O. C. Knapp (Democratic) | 177 |
| 1873 | Cyrus C. Carpenter (Republican) | 364 |
| | J. G. Vale (Democratic) | 228 |
| 1875 | Samuel J. Kirkwood (Republican) | 549 |
| | Shephard Leffler (Democratic) | 406 |
| | J. H. Lozier (Republican) | 3 |
| 1877 | J. H. Gear (Republican) | 888 |
| | John P. Irish (Democratic) | 637 |
| 1879 | John H. Gear (Republican) | 1,133 |
| | H. H. Trimble (Democratic) | 794 |
| | Daniel Campbell (Greenback) | 27 |
| 1881 | B. R. Sherman (Republican) | 1,050 |
| | L. G. Kinnie (Democratic) | 695 |
| | D. M. Clark (Greenback) | 103 |
| 1883 | B. R. Sherman (Republican) | 1,593 |
| | L. G. Kinnie (Democratic) | 1,533 |
| | James B. Weaver (Greenback) | 31 |
| 1885 | William Larrabee (Republican) | 1,544 |
| | Charles E. Whiting (Democratic) | 1,689 |
| 1887 | William Larrabee (Republican) | 1,421 |
| | J. T. Anderson (Democratic) | 1,587 |
| | M. J. Cain (Greenback) | 301 |
