Frank Eichelberger and D. H. Payne were not among the earliest, but may be classed as among the early lawyers of Davis County, for they were members of its bar for a period of nearly fifty years, and I knew them all personally.

Frank Eichelberger, I knew from the time he was a very young man. His father was a hotelkeeper; having been the proprietor of the principal hotel in Muscatine in the early sixties, he became that of the Ottumwa House, formerly kept by John Potter. Frank was not much beyond his majority when he followed the family to Ottumwa. He was some four or five years my junior, and as we were both young and congenial, soon became and continued fast friends. He received his education in the common schools, and when but little more than twenty, was the local editor of the Muscatine Journal, a connection which continued for some four years. He was for a short time an army correspondent of the Chicago Tribune. In 1866 he began his legal studies with Judge Morris J. Williams, at Ottumwa, was duly admitted to the bar and began the practice with Henry C. Traverse, and removed to Bloomfield. Later Mr. Payne was taken into the firm, under the name of Traverse, Payne & Eichelberger. When Traverse was elected judge, the firm became Payne & Eichelberger, and so continued, I think, until Eichelberger's election to the bench.

He was Judge of that District for more than twenty years. He was a man of talents, a well-read lawyer and an able judge. His father and mother were elderly people when they came to Ottumwa. I knew them well. They were well-bred and most excellent persons. Frank had a brother, Thomas, familiarly known as "Tom" Eichelberger. He was highly gifted, a brilliant writer and prominently connected with some of the leading newspapers of the time. He died many years ago in the prime of life.

Judge Eichelberger was a warm-hearted, charming and companionable man; full blooded and a good liver. While at the bar he had a fine practice, took quite an active part in Republican politics, and was generally Chairman of the county delegation in the different conventions of his party. He was a man of wide information, liberal views, and far from being a mere partisan. His innate strength and popularity were well attested by his repeated election as judge, and by other honors before conferred upon him, among which was that of Mayor of the City of Bloomfield.

By EDWARD H. STILES DES MOINES THE HOMESTEAD PUBLISHING CO. 1916

Back to Sketches