USGenWeb  JOHNSON COUNTY
 IAGenWeb Project

Johnson County History

Johnson County Tragic Events


JOHN T. MAIER

UNION TOWNSHIP MAN MEETS SAD FATE LAST NIGHT ON TRACK

 
JOHN T. MAIER’S BODY IS GROUND BENEATH TRAIN
  - Union Township Man Meets Sad Fate Last Night on Track -

John T. Maier whose home is in the southeast corner of Union township, five miles southwest of Iowa City, was ground to death beneath the wheels of a train that entered the city from the east sometime last evening or last night.

Found By Section Men
Section men leaving the city this morning a few minutes after seven were the first to discover the tragedy, coming upon portions of the man’s body strung along the track for some distance. They reported the ghastly find to Coroner J. H. Donohue who went to the scene in East Iowa City.

Coroner Is Called
The bank book of John T. Maier was found along the track and this helped to identify the body which was almost past identification on account of the body being ground into small bits and the face had been dragged in the cinders until it was almost beyond recognition. Later positive identification was made by relatives and friends who were summoned.

Horribly Mangled
The body was mangled almost beyond belief. The point where the head is believed to have first struck the ties is 400 feet west of the Kelly factory in the cut just near the switch runs in. From this point west it is 155 feet to where the main part of the body is found.  It is likely that many trains passed over the body and each must have contributed its share to the horrible deed.

Early Last Night
It is believed that the tragedy occurred early last evening, as every indication seemed to point to the fact that death had occurred many hours before discovery. Examination by Coroner Donohue showed pieces of the internal organism on portions of the running year of a car that was set off a freight train that entered the city at 8:45 last evening. However it might have occurred earlier but not later.

Will Hold Inquest
Coroner Donohue will hold an inquest at the Undertaking parlors where the body now reposes a 7:30 this evening. He has subpoenaed C. Bothel, Frank Smith and George Katzenmeyer as members of the jury to view the scene of the unfortunate occurrence this afternoon, collect all facts available and hold the inquest tonight.

May Be Foul Play
There is no indication that the man met with foul play, although there is no indication that he did not. His brother Frank today stated that the family was unable to conceive of any reason for his being on the tracks east of town when his home is west and south.
It is possible of course that the man might have boarded the train and jumped or fell off, but it seems likely that he was a foot on the tracks.

Came to Town Yesterday
Mr. Maier came to Iowa City early in the day yesterday and was about town all day. He put his team in the feed barn and did not return. Frank stated that he was with his brother in a bank at about two o’clock in the afternoon and various others saw and spoke with him, as he was well known here, up to about 5 o’clock. At that time, John Hart stated that he saw Mr. Maier go past the Mercer Transfer company office. This seems to be the last that was seen of him.

Born in This County
John T. Maier was born in Johnson County forty-two years ago and spent practically all his life here. He was married to Mary Isenhofer, a sister of Joseph Isenhofer of Pleasant Valley township. To this union was born and now survive seven children, the oldest, Edith, a young lady of eighteen, Matilda, Antone, William, Lillian, Agnes, Helen, the latter a baby of two.

He was the son of Mrs. John Maier, who is now Mrs. John Dudlinger, of 320 North Governor St., of this city. His father died when he was very small. He is also survived by four brothers, as follows: John Dudlinger of Cincinnati, William of Page, North Dakota, Frank and Andrew of Union township in this county.

The sympathy of the entire community goes out to the bereaved family in their sadness. Funeral arrangements have not yet been made.
(Source: Iowa City Press-Citizen, Wed, Jan 22, 1919, pg. 1)

MYSTERY STILL UNSOLVED, JURY INVESTIGATION
 – No Conclusion Was Reached at Inquest Over John Maier -

Why should John Maier be upon the railroad tracks in East Iowa City Monday night? Why should he be run over and killed by a freight train and horribly dismembered? Was there foul play of any sort?

These are some of the questions that are being asked on the streets and which Coroner J. H. Donohue and his jury with County Attorney Claude M. Miller are trying to answer in connection with the mysterious death and the finding of the mangled body of John Maier, a prominent farmer of Union township on the Rock Island tracks here yesterday morning by the section men as they went to work.

The inquest began last night with C. Bothel, Frank Smith and George Katzenmeyer as the jury of three. The investigation was held at Undertaker Donohue’s rooms and continued for at least two hours. Many witnesses were summoned and told what they  knew, which was all too little, to shed much light upon the mysterious part of the occurrence.

Carried Big Insurance
It developed that Mr. Maier carried $35,000 life insurance, much of it accident, one policy of which had just been taken out with Deaton and Hoover in the Northwestern and Mr. Deaton testified at the inquest that Mr. Maier came to his office on the fourth floor of the Johnson County bank building after two o’clock Tuesday afternoon and that he delivered to him at that time his policy for $5,000 and the policy was found with the scattered remains along the railroad track the next day.

It also developed that Mr. Maier was a man who often carried large sums of money with him, that is several hundred dollars, but Tuesday afternoon he went to the Johnson County bank and made a deposit of $60 and 440 odd dollars was found on his clothes after death had resulted.

No Foul Play Suspected
Foul play is not believed to have been responsible. Mr. Maier was not a man to make enemies and it does not seem possible that the deed could have been done for revenge alone, as no money is believed to have been taken.

If the object in intended violence from some unknown party had been robbery than the party would doubtless have taken the $40 afterward found in his clothes.

Might Be Suicide
Of course he might have committed suicide. It was remarked that he might have been run over by an aero plane instead of a freight train. Just as likely. John Maier is not believed by his friends to have been the sort of a man to walk out on the railroad track and commit suicide, even though he carried considerable life insurance. Those who knew him best say he would be the last man in the county to perform such a deed, and they refuse to take any stock in such a theory.

Brought Hogs to Town
At the inquest John Isenhofer, a brother in law of the dead man testified that he last saw Maier at 11:00 a.m. when he drove into the Crane and Marner feed barn, where Isenhofer works, and left his team. He had been hauling hogs to town. He left and did not return.

M. L. Deaton testified that the deceased was in his office at 2 p.m. and that he delivered to him a policy of insurance.

John Hart testified that he saw Mr. Maier or someone who answered his description pass the office of the Mercer Transfer company near the old Leinbaugh lumber yards as late as five o’clock, perhaps a little later.

Fred Miller testified that he saw Mr. Maier pass the feed store on Dubuque Street about 4 p.m.
Charles Geazel testified that he saw Maier at the corner of Dubuque and College in front of old Lehnet place about 6 o’clock.

No Conclusion Yet
The evidence before the jury was not of such an order that they were able to come to any intelligent conclusion. They were taken to the scene of the tragedy yesterday afternoon viewed the tracks, examined everything closely and viewed the body.

After considering the evidence last night the inquest was adjourned until this evening when the train crew of the freight that is believed to have killed the man can be summoned and brought here.

At the point where the train struck him there is a double track system. It appears that the man first struct the north rail of the north track.

The theory has been advanced that the unfortunate man may have been meeting a train going east and stepped aside to let it go by and that the freight going west was unnoticed and struck him. Opponents of this theory point out that this would be more likely to happen in the day time than at night, and it now seems certain that it was at night and that the tragedy occurred, as the powerful headlight would, they believe, have undoubtedly attracted the attention of the man, whereas the sound might not.

It is also surmised that possibly the train that struck him might have been running without lights. This would account for their not seeing the man, in the first place and for their not knowing that they had hit him. On the other hand it is pointed out that train men using due caution in entering a city should have been looking ahead and should have seen the man, even though he might have been slugged and lying on the track, unless per chance they had been without lights.


IN MEMORY OF JOHN T. MAIER
Jan 21, 1919

Union Township, Jan 24 – This community has been shocked in the recent tragedy involving the death of John T. Maier, who was a life time resident of this vicinity. Mr. Maier was born on the farm which he now owns forty-two years ago and has spent his entire life in union township where he will be greatly missed as he was one of Johnson county’s most up to date and successful farmers, a leader among men, always at the head of most every undertaking in the community.  By his skillful farming tactics, he has become owner of about four hundred acres of land which he cultivated by the aid of tractors.

He was a lover of home life and his loss will be keenly felt by his wife, formerly Miss Isenhofer and seven children, all at home. They are Ida, age 18; Tilla, 16; Agnes S, 8; Lillian, 6; William, 12; Andrew, 10 and Baby Helen 1 ˝.

His mother, Mrs. John Dutlinger and several step brothers also survive to mourn his loss besides a host of friends and neighbors whom he won by his cheerful disposition and fair dealings toward all.
The entire community extends their sympathy to the bereaved wife and children whom death has robbed of a loving husband and father.