| Gertrude Beard | Grace Besack | Elizabeth Besack | Erma Bish |
| Florence Maud Blair | Earle Burnell | Bertley A. Clutter | Grace Cook |
| Clifford V. Cox | Herman F. Dahlgren | Rena P. Drew | Mamie Earley |
| Will V. Eberhart | Corinne Harvey1 | James C. Hill | Clifford W. Manning |
| Edith Matthews | Etta M. Northup | Gertrude Parsons | Albert Secor |
| Valeria M. Secor | |||
| Source: The Newton Record, May 29, 1896, End of School Days. | |||
| 1. Not listed in Special Alumni Edition of Newtonia, March 6, 1924 | |||